13 blue chips hiding in plain sight

Illustration: Karl HilzingerWhat stocks to pick? We’ve tried to make things a little bit easier for you by providing a short list of the businesses that have had the steadiest earnings profile over the past 10 years.

Most investors know Woolworths and Commonwealth Bank of Australia are some of the most reliable earners listed on the ASX. That’s a big reason why they are considered the bluest of blue-chip stocks. But if a steady earnings profile makes a blue-chip stock, then the list would extend beyond the top 50 to include other names – some better known than others – such as, Mermaid Marine, Silver Chef and Corporate Travel Management.

What most investors want when they buy shares in a company is exposure to a business that’s on a firm financial footing, a history of steady earnings growth, and decent prospects – all at a reasonable price. Sounds simple, really – except we all know it’s not.

But we’ve tried to make things a little bit easier for you by measuring the stability of earnings, operating income and dividends paid of each and every one of the biggest 300 listed companies by market capitalisation, to come up with a short list of the businesses that have had the steadiest earnings profile over the past 10 years.

More from Smart Investor: 

• Ten oil and gas stocks to tap into

• Ten stocks you just can’t live without

• Ten stocks to satisfy a hunger for value

As you can see from the table, there are a couple of the 13 names that have had less than a decade of earnings experience – Carsales with eight and Corporate Travel Management with five – but we’ve decided to include them on the basis that they score highly and a record of five years is enough to get a handle on how reliable an earner a business is.

As alluded to above, the main criterion is the earnings per share stability score. The term measures how closely actual data tracks a linear trend line. A score of approaching one indicates the next period’s EPS is almost perfectly predictable based on past results. A stability score of zero suggests a company with an extremely volatile bottom line, which means yesterday’s earnings give no guidance to tomorrow’s.

As a secondary insight, we also calculated the stability of operating income and dividends.

Of course, no single metric is perfect. For example, mining services company Monadelphous would have been our 14th stock, except the only thing you can reliably predict for businesses in that corner of the market is that, compared to the past decade, they are going to it tough in the coming years.

We have kept Mermaid Marine – our second most reliable earner – in the list, as demand for the services they provide to offshore oil and gas industry off the coast of north-western Australia should remain relatively stable in a world where the demand for energy goes up.

That might sound simplistic, and it is, but, again, this screen is designed as a place for you to start your research, rather than end it.

There are some more predictable names on the list, such as supermarket giant Woolworths and a pair of companies operating in the traditionally steady healthcare space – hospital owner and operator Ramsay Health Care and global blood plasma products firm CSL.

When it comes to our list of reliable earners, “steady” shouldn’t be confused with “slow”. The median annual EPS growth for the 13 stocks is 19, compounded, over the past seven years. Return on equity averages 22 per cent. Leading the charge in that regard are online classified businesses and REA Group, which runs, as well as other property sites globally.

More from Smart Investor:

• Skaffold’s top three value stocks

• Six growth stocks with an edge

• Twelve stocks on a high-conviction hit list

Retailers vying for our discretionary dollar also get a guernsey, despite lower consumer spending patterns that appear to be both cyclical and structural. Four-wheel drive accessory maker and seller ARB Corp has a glorious history of rewarding shareholders in terms of both share price performance and dividends, and in truth is most likely the company outside the top 50 with the bluest blood in its veins.

Discount electronics store JB Hi-Fi continues to prove the doubters wrong, although this festive season will be a crucial one for all retailers. The stock has surged 90 per cent this year.

Which brings us to the final – and perhaps most challenging – aspect of investing: finding value.

Most of the names on this market have been recognised and rewarded over the past year, as you can see from their elevated price-to-earnings ratios, which average 20 against the market at closer to 14 or 15.

Woolworths shares on a P/E of 17 maybe look a little better value; after all, you would expect it to trade at a premium to the market given its quality and history. Mermaid Marine’s stock price is actually lower now than it was at the start of the year, and is trading on the lowest multiple.

Given the rapid growth in some of the companies on our list, we’ve also listed the price-to-earnings growth, or PEG, ratio, which provides a guide for the value of a business based on expected long-term EPS growth. A score below 1 implies good value, and while not cheap, at 1.3 and 1.4, Carsales, REA Group and Super Retail Group look better value than most.

Company Industry EPS stability score** Operating income stability score DPS stability score (incl est. DPS) Share price ($) YTD share price performance (%) Est. price/ earnings PEG ratio Dividend yield (%) 7-yr compound annual EPS growth (%)
Carsales* Online classifieds            0.99            0.99            0.83        9.73        30.7        23.7 1.3          3.0        42.2
Mermaid Marine Engineering services            0.97            0.97            0.87        3.27       (4.7)         12.5 4.3          3.8        21.9
Silver Chef Equipment hire            0.96            0.89            0.85        7.45        29.3        17.0 N/a          3.8        16.3
Woolworths Retail            0.95            0.97            0.83      33.69        14.4        17.1 3.2          4.0        10.4
ARB Corp Vehicle accessories            0.94            0.95            0.81      12.32        11.2        20.9 5.7          2.3        13.8
Ramsay Health Care Hospital owner            0.93            0.99            0.85      38.74        43.5        25.2 2          1.8        18.5
REA Group Online classifieds            0.93            0.95            0.87      40.51      124.6        37.9 1.4          1.0        42.7
Corporate Travel Mgt* Corporate travel            0.93            0.98            0.84        5.78        55.5        26.5 N/a          1.9 -
Super Retail Group Retail            0.92            0.84            0.88      13.69        37.3        20.5 1.4          2.6        18.8
CBA Banking            0.92              0.9            0.73      77.82        23.6        15.4 2.1          4.7 6.5
JB Hi-Fi Retail            0.92            0.89            0.89        20.4        90.2        16.1 2.8          3.7        25.0
Sky Network Television TV            0.91            0.76            0.72        5.07        34.0        14.3 N/a          4.2        12.5
CSL Biotech            0.91            0.83            0.97      68.73        25.6        23.5 1.7          1.6        44.1

*Carsales has 8 years of EPS history, and Corporate Travel has 5 years. **EPS stability score includes 10 years’ earnings including estimates for this financial year. Source: S&P Capital IQ, Bloomberg, Smart Investor. Data as at December 1, 2013.


Market Summary

Price % Chg
CGF CHALLENGER $ 6.720 + 4.19%
SXL STHNXMEDIA $ 1.375 + 4.17%
PBG PACBRANDS $ 0.535 + 3.88%
SXY SENEX $ 0.740 + 3.50%
CRZ CARSALES $ 10.750 + 3.07%
CSR CSR $ 3.760 + 3.01%
JHX J HARDIE $ 13.630 + 2.87%
NWH NRWHOLDLTD $ 1.155 + 2.67%
SAI SAI GLOBAL $ 4.270 + 2.64%
IIN IINET $ 7.190 + 2.57%


Price Change % Chg
BRENT SPOT (USD/BBL) 110.230 0.000 0.00%
LIGHT CRUDE MAY4 (USD/BBL) 104.590 + 0.540 + 0.52%
NAT GAS MAY14 (USD/MMBTU) 4.735 + 0.211 + 4.66%
Bid Ask Bid Chg Bid % Chg
GOLD (USD/OZ) 1294.35 1295.35 + 0.00 + 0.00%
SILVER (USD/OZ) 19.59 19.69 + 0.00 + 0.00%
PLATINUM (USD/OZ) 1404.80 1414.80 + 0.00 + 0.00%
PALLADIUM (USD/OZ) 794.00 800.00 + 0.00 + 0.00%

Markets Data »


AUD AUD 0.9323 0.6749 95.52 0.5554
USD 1.0722 USD 0.724 102.43 0.5957
EUR 1.4806 1.3809 EUR 141.50 0.8227
JPY 0.0105 0.0098 0.0071 JPY 0.0058
GBP 1.7993 1.6782 1.2149 171.9 GBP

Markets Data »

Stock price lookup

My Watchlists

You need to be logged in to see your watchlists.

My Portfolios

You need to be logged in to see your portfolios.